We left off last week with an admonition on grade inflation. If you are a contributor to grade inflation, at whatever level of university teaching or administration, you have sacrificed your standards of merit and excellence to something else. Read on.
The article, by Yascha Mounk, was “College Grades Have Become a Charade. It is Time to Abolish Them,” published by the Wall Street Journal..
Let’s look at some statistics from the U. S News and World Report, the standard for college and university statistics. Since grades are not routinely made available to nosy journalists, we’ll look at some other stats for the time being.
I looked at Georgia Tech where I have a granddaughter in her freshman year, and at Auburn and UA since I’m here in Alabama and taught at UA for forty years.
In national rankings, Tech ranked #33, Auburn #93, and UA #170. Tech’s acceptance rate was 17% of applicants, Auburn accepted 44%, and UA accepted 80%.
At 170th in the ranking, UA was tied with a number of schools, including Mercer University, University of Hawaii, Kansas State University, Florida A & M, and one or two others.
Given that colleges and universities as a whole award about 80% As in their grades, MounK notes candidly that “the grading system at American universities is an embarrassment,” and “it’s time for universities to admit that the emperor has no clothes. If reestablishing more demanding standards turns out to be impossible, then the second best option may be to put an end to the whole charade.”
Mounk’s “modest” solution: “Universities would make all of their courses pass-fail, a practice that has already been adopted by some elite law and business schools. Students would still have to submit their assignments and meet the minimum standards that are now expected of them. But they would no longer be able to pretend that they had been recognized for exceptional achievements.”
Frustratingly, Moulk continues: “Sometimes, a system becomes so irredeemably broken that the least bad option is to give up on it, at least for the time being. The grading system at American universities has now reached that stage. Imperfect though that solution may be, it’s time to bin the whole damn thing. And perhaps, in ten or thirty or fifty years, that will allow us to start from scratch.”
Moulk has other analysis and conclusions which you can read yourselves. “As many a professor and teaching assistant will be happy to attest,” he writes, “the best way to get a student to complain—and create a needless bureaucratic headache for yourself—is to give them a B+ for subpar work when they are used to getting an A-.”
Returning to my student from last week’s column who came to me with a request for an A in the course. I didn’t remember seeing him in class and he had a couple of lame excuses.
I looked into my grade book and told him, “well I’ve only got a few Ds and Fs left for this class.” He looked at me puzzled. “Which do you want?” I asked.

“Best Student Ever” Cup Awarded to all DEI Students
He left, disgusted I thought with having signed up for a class with this old codger who actually expected you to be in class, turn off your tablet and laptop off, read the assignments, and take notes. What an antique!
I do not like to point out flaws in the system without also pointing to a solution or two. The flaws are largely attributable to the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) system put in place about fifteen or twenty years ago. We can return to that later since the Woke culture has undermined so much of what is good in America, such as employing merit as the way to measure work and success.
A few years ago I suggested establishing an Alpha College at any university willing to sponsor and fund a return to merit and study as the signposts of success and achievement, instead of DEI’s structure of looking at other factors such as race, ethnicity, sexual preferences, etc. etc. as the determinants of success and advancement in higher education or the work place.
Alabama universities and colleges are in fact under an order made by the State Legislature to [here quote from that legislative act}. UA has largely ignored the order by simply renaming DEI offices and instructions on its campus.
So, what to do re. DEI and grade inflation which has earned UA a national ranking along with those listed above, like Mercer and the University of Hawaii? I can’t eliminate DEI or change the grade structure of an institution with so much power and money at stake.
However, I have seen institutions of higher learning establish small, specialized colleges, like New College once was at UA, to pursue learning in a true and faithful fashion with what really is important in higher education in this country.
Posted on September 24, 2024
0